
Photography by Stephanie Arsenault
PHOTOGRAPHY BY STEPHANIE ARSENAULT DEANNA SANDOVAL
styling by Deanna Sandoval, Logan Mitchell, and Katie Stokes
The three recipes for this year’s Cook the Cover were delicious as submitted, but our guest chefs still had a little fun in the test kitchen. As chef Eduardo Cortes put it, they simply couldn’t resist “cheffing it up.”
Chef Rocío Siso-Gurriarán (MIHO) added wine, a bay leaf, and paprika to the sauce for her take on Bayshore Court Baked Shrimp, giving an Iberian flair to this savory dish.

Chef Ashley McBrady (MAKE CAFE) stayed fairly close to the recipe for Not Your Nonna’s Meatballs!, but felt called to give it a Mediterranean twist. She added crumbled feta to keep the meatballs moist, extra lemon for brightness, and eggs to help bind everything together a little better. These meatballs will be delicious served over any pasta, rice, or even sautéed greens, but McBrady made fresh orecchiette in honor of all Nonnas.

Chef Cortes (Alchemy – Choose Thy Poison) took the most dramatic approach to Crispy Mashed Potato Tacos, putting his own spin on a Mexico City staple. He mixed squid ink into half of the yellow corn masa, creating a striking black-and-yellow tortilla, then folded crumbled, sautéed chorizo into the potato filling. The result was a crisp tortilla filled with cheesy potato and chorizo that still felt surprisingly light and balanced. Cortes finished the tacos with avocado salsa, pickled tomatillos and onions, a drizzle of crema, and fresh mint.

While each chef imparted flavorful practices and playful personal touches to elevate the presentation of their chosen dish for a chance at having it featured on the cover, the results stayed true to the original recipes. And that’s the thing about recipes—they’re always part original, part making do with what ingredients are on hand, part adding in techniques and seasonings you’re partial to, and discovering new ways to make them your own.
Cook the Cover recipes are edited for clarity and published to reflect the original submissions.

Recipe by Dianne F. Collatos
Selected by Rocío Siso-Gurriarán
“Miami Pinks” run through Biscayne Bay all winter long. They peak during full moons, in obscenely large schools. Back in the early ‘90s, my mother Flossie and her friend Everette Swan often ventured out to catch them. By the light of the silvery moon, they gunned his Whaler into the bay from our home on Bayshore Court in Coconut Grove, FL. Their laughter (undoubtedly aided by martinis and Crown Royale) could be heard by many who lived along our sea-walled waterfront. Once at the bridge, they would drift with lights ablaze, dipping their handheld nets to catch bucketloads of shrimp. The night waters were illuminated by large lamps hung all over boats and from the bridge by a united nation of fishermen. It was the most memorable and fun time of the winter season when they ran.
The next day at lunch, we would cook up this simple and fresh meal—the best! There were always plenty of shrimp to share with the neighbors and friends, plus friendly cats and dogs that “Swannie” entertained from under his umbrella out on the bay until the wee hours of the night.

Recipe by Laura Oversmith
Selected by Ashley McBrady
This recipe was inspired by combining my love of Italian cooking with an unconventional meat that truly reinvents Nonna’s meatballs. It honors my traditional family meatballs and pasta while supporting our local fishing community with ground opah from TunaVille Market and Grocery. I used herbs and lemons from my garden to flavor the meatballs, and the sauce I made was simple, with simmered red pomodoro datterino and yellow datterino tomatoes (I like the Giadzy brand and have also used the Di Napoli brand), smashed garlic cloves, a grating of nutmeg, dried oregano, sea salt, lemon zest, and pepper. If you like it hot, add some Calabrian chile flakes.
This recipe will work well with any reader’s Nonna’s sauce and favorite pasta shape. The meatballs do not taste like fish at all—instead, they’re a celebration of thinking outside a traditional recipe to create a version that goes from boat to table!

Recipe by Lindsay Smith
Selected by Eduardo Cortes
My grandmother was an amazing self-taught cook. The woman had no limits. She killed it at baking, could grill the perfect steak, and prepare a scallop like nobody’s business. Whether it was veal parm or grilled cheese, it was always restaurant quality. But she really excelled at Thanksgiving. Always inherited recipes, always the same menu, and always an abundance of leftovers. When she passed away when I was 17, I took over. I didn’t want that tradition to go away. While I’ve added to and updated her original dishes, the leftovers are still in abundance—and what to do with them is always a question.
After I had my children, one of the traditions we started as a family was celebrating Taco Tuesday in various iterations. So what else was I going to do with leftover mashed potatoes but turn them into a crispy taco? I layer Thanksgiving mashed potatoes smothered with cheese in tortillas, then fry them up. Served alongside crema and fresh tomatillo salsa, you have a dish that’s not just leftover-worthy, but craveable all year round.

Food for Cook the Cover proudly sponsored by Jimbo’s.
A special thank you to MIHO creative event studio for generously hosting the Cook the Cover test kitchen.
Opah gifted by TunaVille Market and Grocery.
This article originally published in issue 84.

Stephanie Arsenault is an Oceanside-based food and travel writer and photographer who is also WSET-certified and a Prud’homme-certified beer geek. She loves nothing more than spending a day baking, pickling, or gathering friends around the table for a dinner party. Get your hands on a copy of Stephanie’s book, 111 Places in San Diego That You Must Not Miss, and follow her culinary and travel adventures on Instagram @globaldish or her website globaldish.ca.
STAY IN TOUCH
Our Latest Issue Is Online Now!
‘A FRESH TAKE’
SPRING 2025